| League | Team | Owner | Record |
|---|
| A League About Nothing | The Owls Are Not What They Seem | John Hula | 5-10 (.333) |
| A League About Nothing | Wayne Knights | Mark Currie | 4-11 (.267) |
| American Association | Brooklyn Grays | Sherman Wan | 6-9 (.400) |
| American Association | Cincinnati Country Gentlemen | Robert Elias | 7-8 (.467) |
| Anchorman League | Cooperstown Wannabes | David Henning | 7-8 (.467) |
| B Movie Actor League | Busey's Blasters | Dave Matter | 6-9 (.400) |
| B Movie Actor League | Spaghetti Westerns | Andrew Lehman | 7-8 (.467) |
| Batman League | Gotham City Knights | Jon Swanson | 7-8 (.467) |
| Batman League | Waterbury Riddlers | Mike Scott | 5-10 (.333) |
| Beatleball | London Groovejet Armada | Sherman Wan | 5-10 (.333) |
| Beer League | Hornsby's Rhinos | Don Kruse | 6-9 (.400) |
| Big Red Machine League | Kingston Red Stripe Beer | Ricardo Alexander | 7-8 (.467) |
| Big Red Machine League | Mike's Forever Boys | Sherman Wan | 7-8 (.467) |
| Big Red Machine League | Valley Forge Continentals | Robert Elias | 7-8 (.467) |
| Birdland | Annapolis Crabbers | Dave Matter | 3-12 (.200) |
| Birdland | Flock of Seagulls | Michael Lehman | 3-12 (.200) |
| Birdland | NYC2ATL Jr. Eagles | Ricardo Alexander | 4-11 (.267) |
| Blame Canada League | Elsinore Hosers | Jerry King | 6-9 (.400) |
| Blame Canada League | Vancouver Ruffians | David Henning | 5-10 (.333) |
| Bleed Dodger Blue | New New York Mets | Jamie Reese | 6-9 (.400) |
| Blue and Gray League | Charleston Cannon Fodder | Jerry King | 7-8 (.467) |
| Blue and Gray League | Harpers Ferry Raiders | Dave Matter | 4-11 (.267) |
| Blue and Gray League | Lincoln Logs | Andrew Lehman | 7-8 (.467) |
| Born to Run League | Central City Flashes | David Henning | 7-8 (.467) |
| Born to Run League | Nebraska Grasshoppers | Rick Furtak | 6-9 (.400) |
| Born to Run League | Stole Home Alone | Andrew Lehman | 3-12 (.200) |
| British Invasion League | Time of the Season | Jamie Reese | 6-9 (.400) |
| British Invasion League | Waterloo Sunset | Mike Scott | 6-9 (.400) |
| Broadway League | Rochelle Rochelle | Michael Rudolph | 6-9 (.400) |
| Bronx Bombers League | Louisville Ultimate Sluggers | David Henning | 4-11 (.267) |
| Bronx Bombers League | Polo Grounds Homer Hitters | Craig Burke | 2-13 (.133) |
| Bronx Bombers League | Staten Island Jokers | Dave Matter | 7-8 (.467) |
| Chevy Chase League | Sogndal Spies | Dave Matter | 3-12 (.200) |
| Cleveland Rocks | Wonton Soup | Benchwarmer Baseball League Office | 7-8 (.467) |
| Commissioners League | Budapest Buskers | Jon Swanson | 5-10 (.333) |
| Deuces Wild League | Deuce on the Loose | Andrew Lehman | 2-13 (.133) |
| Deuces Wild League | Savannah Engineers | Willis Lee | 3-12 (.200) |
| Experts League | Fantasy Couch | Ken Stevenson | 3-12 (.200) |
| Federal League | Buffalo Wings over America | Michael Lehman | 6-9 (.400) |
| Firemen League | Chicago Fire | Tom McGraw | 5-10 (.333) |
| Firemen League | House of Leary | Benchwarmer Baseball League Office and Foster Hula | 7-8 (.467) |
| Five Boroughs League | Manhattan Magillas | Dave Matter | 7-8 (.467) |
| Five Boroughs League | Shaolin Killa Bees | John Hula | 5-10 (.333) |
| Four Star League | NYC2ATL Jr Blackbirds | Ricardo Alexander | 5-10 (.333) |
| Four Star League | Upstream Boogie | Jim Duzyk | 7-8 (.467) |
| Game Night League | Loose Cobra | Jim Duzyk | 7-8 (.467) |
| Game Night League | Minnesota Moose | Jon Swanson | 7-8 (.467) |
| Geek Pride League | Boba Chette Salutes Greef Karga | Sherman Wan | 7-8 (.467) |
| Geek Pride League | Seattle Grunge | Dave Matter | 4-11 (.267) |
| Geek Pride League | Three Dollar Bill | Tom McGraw | 4-11 (.267) |
| Golden Throat League | Atlantic City Hi-Rollers | Tom McGraw | 6-9 (.400) |
| Golden Throat League | St. Louis Browns | Michael Quinn | 6-9 (.400) |
| Gone But Not Forgotten League | Ebbets Field Duke's Sliders | Derrick Silensky | 7-8 (.467) |
| Grand Slam League | Fritz's German Sausage | Alonda Clifton | 7-8 (.467) |
| Grand Slam League | Moons Over My Hammy | Sherman Wan | 7-8 (.467) |
| Grand Slam League | Washington Lobbyists | Yuri Belova | 6-9 (.400) |
| Great Lakes League | Grand Haven Love Shacks | John Hula | 6-9 (.400) |
| Hall of Fame League | San Diego Surfriders | John Hula | 6-9 (.400) |
| Home of the Brave | I've Seen Your Face Before My Friend | Sherman Wan | 7-8 (.467) |
| Home of the Brave | Martin's Ferry Knuckleheads | Dave Matter | 6-9 (.400) |
| K Street League | Wayne Mad Generals | Robert Elias | 7-8 (.467) |
| Longball League | Gettysburg Bicycle Repairmen | Jon Swanson | 5-10 (.333) |
| Longball League | Trinidad Island Vikings | Leif Jonson | 7-8 (.467) |
| Longball League | Twin Peaks Percolators | John Hula | 7-8 (.467) |
| Marxball | Adolph's Harpsters | Dave Matter | 5-10 (.333) |
| Marxball | Euclid Beach Bums | Michael Rudolph | 6-9 (.400) |
| Minnie & Paul League | Kansas City Monarchs | Don Kruse | 5-10 (.333) |
| Minnie & Paul League | Nebraska Legends | Michael Gaston | 7-8 (.467) |
| Moneyball League | Atlanta Beane Pies | Ricardo Alexander | 6-9 (.400) |
| Moneyball League | Rich Kids | Benchwarmer Baseball League Office and Tom McGraw | 5-10 (.333) |
| Moneyball League | TINSTAAPP Leifs | Leif Jonson | 7-8 (.467) |
| Motor City League | Alcubierre-Obousy Skunkworks | Sherman Wan | 7-8 (.467) |
| Murderers' Row | Atlanta Bronx Bombers | Ricardo Alexander | 6-9 (.400) |
| Murderers' Row | Palookaville Pugs | Sherman Wan | 7-8 (.467) |
| Murderers' Row | Wittenberg Theses | Jon Swanson | 6-9 (.400) |
| North Siders League | Chicago Prophets | Rick Furtak | 7-8 (.467) |
| North Siders League | Waypoint Spartans | David Henning | 4-11 (.267) |
| Original Six League | Montreal Maroons | Michael Rudolph | 7-8 (.467) |
| Pacific Northwest League | Spokane Royals | Michael Quinn | 5-10 (.333) |
| Perfect World League | Red Robins | Jamie Reese | 4-11 (.267) |
| Phightin' Phils League | Fairborn Flying Angels | David Henning | 6-9 (.400) |
| Reality Bites | Carmel Surf Dogs | Andrew Lehman | 5-10 (.333) |
| Reality Bites | Interlaken Kaselogistik | Sherman Wan | 4-11 (.267) |
| Reality Bites | Minneapolis Coonhounds | Jon Swanson | 4-11 (.267) |
| Reality Bites | Real Thing | Benchwarmer Baseball League Office and Anthony C | 5-10 (.333) |
| Redbirds League | Brooklyn Usual Suspects | Jerry King | 7-8 (.467) |
| Royal Flush League | Appierances Can Be Deceiving | Sherman Wan | 5-10 (.333) |
| Royal Flush League | Cleves Rolling The Bones | Alonda Clifton | 7-8 (.467) |
| Royal Flush League | West Bottoms Hungry Heifers | Dave Matter | 7-8 (.467) |
| Shadowball League | Bedrock Water Buffaloes | Leif Jonson | 6-9 (.400) |
| Shadowball League | Kingston Bob Marleys | Ricardo Alexander | 7-8 (.467) |
| Shadowball League | Stockholm Socialists | Jon Swanson | 4-11 (.267) |
| South Siders League | The Thing From the Junk Drawer | Andrew Lehman | 7-8 (.467) |
| South Siders League | Wimpy's Hawks | Dave Matter | 7-8 (.467) |
| Steel City League | Three Rivers Pierogies | Jon Swanson | 7-8 (.467) |
| Superman League | Bully Boys | Tom McGraw | 7-8 (.467) |
| Superman League | Machu Picchu Evil Llamas | Alonda Clifton | 6-9 (.400) |
| That's the Fact Jack League | Passage Tombs | Jim Duzyk | 7-8 (.467) |
| That's the Fact Jack League | Winger's Warriors | Michael Rudolph | 5-10 (.333) |
| The Kings of Queens | Astoria Argyle Sox | Sherman Wan | 7-8 (.467) |
| The Kings of Queens | Grapeville Gunslingers | Jim Duzyk | 7-8 (.467) |
| The Kings of Queens | Woodside Dingos | John Stroba | 6-9 (.400) |
| They Might Be Giants | Gilroy Garlic Gulls | Sherman Wan | 3-12 (.200) |
| ThirtyThirtysomething League | Oklahoma Black Gold | Phillip Dang | 7-8 (.467) |
| ThirtyThirtysomething League | The Thunder Down Under | Michael Lehman | 3-12 (.200) |
| Three of a Kind League | The Three Amigos | Leif Jonson | 4-11 (.267) |
| Triple Crown League | Cincinnati Bench Full of Roses | Dave Matter | 7-8 (.467) |
| Triple Crown League | Mars Attacks!!!!!!!! | Andrew Lehman | 6-9 (.400) |
| Wes Anderson League | Redneck Ric's Roadkill Diner | Michael Lehman | 5-10 (.333) |
| Whiff League | Cyclonic Swingers | Dave Matter | 7-8 (.467) |
| White Elephant League | Titan Rockets | David Henning | 6-9 (.400) |
| Will Ferrell League | Kentucky Bluegrass | J.C. Freeman | 6-9 (.400) |
| Winners Circle League | Florida Hammerheads | Ken Stevenson | 7-8 (.467) |
| Winners Circle League | Los Angeles Baconators | Michael Lehman | 5-10 (.333) |
